As Asian country goes for a free fall thanks to Covid and lockdown, insensitive would be too delicate a word to characterize the Modi government’s shameful handling of the crisis. the plight of migrant staff on the roads and inside trucks, another day in the workplace for masterful minister Nirmala Sitharaman bulldozing her manner through hard questions about the economy that may now not be set aside. 2 months into this unprecedented health and economic crisis, it’s time to assess the Narendra Modi government’s response to the present disaster.
Let us not be unfair to the government. I have supported Prime Minister Modi once he 1st declared the lockdown, while noting that its preparation, temporal arrangement and communication left a lot of to be desired. The PM was decisive once a tough decision had to be taken. Indecision or more delay might have landed USA in an exceedingly worse state than we tend to are. In retrospect, we currently apprehend that our response was already delayed, however it’d be unfair to charge the govt on it basis. international data and awareness at that point failed to warrant such a response. On balance, we reacted quicker than most different countries.
It would even be unfair guilty the Modi government for all the mess that we face today. A mostly unexpected pandemic is certain to produce havoc, even within the better of places. it’s bound to be worse in an exceedingly country like India, given the weak public health fundamentals and fragile response systems. associate degree indictment of the Modi government must take care concerning limiting itself to what might are anticipated, what could have been achieved in our conditions. And it must leave area for genuine mistakes. Janus-faced with a crisis of this kind, the simplest of leaders with the purest intentions can create inaccurate calls. they have to be criticised, however not indicted for existent errors of judgement.
Sadly, even once creating of these allowances, it’s arduous to flee the conclusion that Narendra Modi government has unsuccessful Asian country in its hour of need. the govt has been uninformed concerning dominant the health crisis, incompetent in handling its economic consequence and insensitive in handling the humanitarian crisis.
A failing health model
Let us begin with the health crisis. we tend to should not to blame PM Modi for his early choices in pandemic management. we tend to cannot charge him for error-prone on the aspect of caution as a result of the detected (as all international leaders did) conflicting forecasts about the progress of the pandemic. however, we must raise some queries nevertheless: why did the govt not hear different voices concerning a lot of testing at associate degree early stage? Why did the PM not attempt to learn from and replicate the Kerala model? Did he enable political envy to trump national interest? Why did he not return down heavily against his supporters attempting to communalize the pandemic? Once it became clear that the lockdown wasn’t ‘breaking the chain’ or flattening the curve, why did he stick to the imprisonment because of the sole remedy? Did he allow his ego and self-image to trump rational course correction? And finally, why isn’t any senior skilled worker (not even a minister, including the top of the govt, as is that the norm in several countries) responding to the media’s questions on the pandemic? what’s the long-run strategy? Is there one thing that the government desires to hide?